October 6th 2011 ( Day 8 )
People's 162: A photograph of the saline bag, IV stand,
and depressed plunger attached to the Y-connector
People's 163: Close-up of the syringe hanging from infusion set
People's 164: photograph of BOSE radio player and a CD
People's 165: June 25th 2009 photograph taken of bathroom;
black jacket with orange lining on floor
People's 166: bathroom from different angle (from closet?)
Walgren references peoples 117 (the syringe with no needle attached),
and then references peoples 120 (close-up of the catheter found on the ground).
Elissa Fleak mischaracterized the items as a "broken syringe"; the parts do not go together.
There is nothing broken or defective on either of the items.
The 10cc syringe has a circular tip; the catheter has a square tip.
They do not belong together/ they do not fit together.
Elissa Fleak's thumbprint found on 10cc syringe.
Elissa Fleak subpoenaed CM for medical records; none of the records obtained
pertained to the events surrounding June 25th 2009 nor the care provided
around May/June of 2009.
People's 161: Subpoenaed Medical Records
No allergies/Drug reactions
"NO" Blood Products (religion)
no known allergies:
Medication Log "Omar Arnold (MJJ)":
1/11/06 (January 1st 2006) "Omar Arnold":
1/31/07 (January 31st 2007) Insurance Card:
1/11/08 (January 11th 2008 ) Paul Farnce (MJJ):
2/1/07 (February 1st 2007) Dr. John Code/Cole?:
1/31/07 (January 31st 2007) MEDCO Insurance Card:
Fax Cover Sheet:
Blank Form/Financial Policy:
Blank Patient Consent Form:
Medical Publication / Depigmenting Agent:
(didn't screen cap next page):
...
Paul Farance (MJJ)
DOB: 8/8/2008 lolol/
Exam Date November 13th 2007 (11/13/07) :
11/13/07 "11:11"
Patient Michael Jackson
DOB: 08/29/58 August 29th 1958
DOS: 09/29/08 September 9th 2008
insomnia but otherwise great health:
Handwritten notes patient Omar Arnold:
2/1/08 (February 1st 2008 ) Patient Michael Jackson
cough, nasal congestion, chills,
"All in family sick":
4/12/07 (April 12th, 2007) Patient Michael Jackson
3/07/07 (March 7th 2007) Patient Michael Jackson
3/07 (March 2007) Handwritten progress notes Patiant Omar Arnold (MJJ)
[same page] 4/12/07 (April 12th 2007)
[same page] 3/1/08 (February 1st 2008 )
07/24/06 (July 24th 2006) Patient Michael Jackson
7/24/06 (July 24th 2006) Patient Omar Arnold,
handwritten notes
01/11/06 (January 11th 2006) Patient Michael Jackson
01/11/06 (January 11th 2006) Handwritten notes for
Patient Omar Arnold
Handwritten notes "Michael"
Robitussin
Ornicef
Nasonex
2/10/07 (February 10th 2007) Prescriptions
Omar Arnold/ Paul France
Exam Date: January 17th 2007 "Echocardiograph Report"
Last Name: JACKSON First Name: MICHAEL
Last Modified: January 19th 2007 12:15:45am
Exam Date: January 17th 2007 "Echocardiograph Report"
Last Name: OMAR First Name: ARNOLD
Last Modified: January 19th 2007 12:15:45am
Exam Date: November 13th 2007 - MRI right wrist (tower saint john's imaging)
Patient Paul Farance
DOB: 08/08/2008
Second page of MRI - FARANCE, PAUL
DOE: 11/13/2007 (November 13th 2007)
Validated and Electronically signed 11/13/2007 11:11
Exam Date: November 13th 2007 - MRI right knee (tower saint john's imaging)
Patient Paul Farance (MJJ)
DOB: 08/08/2008
Steinberg Diagnostics Medical Imaging Centers
Exam Date: 3/26/07 (March 26th 2007)
Patient: Michael Jackson
Steinberg Diagnostics Medical Imaging Centers
Exam Date: 3/26/07 (March 26th 2007)
Patient: SMYTHE, MIKE/ OMAR, ARNOLD
Exam Date: November 13th 2007 (tower saint john's imaging)
Patient: FARANCE, PAUL
These records represent completely and entirely all the records related to
MJ provided by CM to Elissa Fleak through his attorney Ed Chernoff.
June 25th 2009 - Elissa Fleak was in charge of collecting and chronicling evidence,
in conjunction with LAPD, & a crime scene photographer.
June 29th 2009 - She returned to the scene because Detective Smith told her there
was additional medical evidence to collect from a room to the side of the bedroom.
Detective Smith was told there were bags in a closet.
Chernoff reviews People's exhibit 128, 129, 134, 135
Elissa Fleak took the bags from the closet, took pictures of them, their contents,
then laid the contents out on the table (Chernoff shows defense exhibit M)
Defense M: crumbled packaging from the blue costco bag
Defense N: another picture taken of the same items
Defense O: another picture, items moved around
Chernoff reviews people's 28 (photograph of 100mL propofol bottle on top
of the saline bag)
EF did not indicate the propofol bottle was inside the saline bag in her June 29th notes.
Chernoff reviews people's 100: asks about flumazenil bottle and where she found it (she found it
on the floor).
Chernoff reviews people's 116: flumazenil is shown on the table, even though she reportedly found it on
floor. EF says she found the flumazenil on the floor and then moved it
to the table prior to the documentation of this photo.
Chernoff reviews people's 117: photo of the 10cc syringe; EF found it on the table as is, so why
is her thumbprint on it? She doesn't know.
Chernoff reviews people's 115: photo of oxygen tank on dolly, ambu bag on floor; points out EF's mistake
of calling the catheter a broken off needle.
Defense P: defense's angle of the ambu bag and catheter on the floor, corner of the couch showing.
Defense Q: photograph of the side of the bed, latex gloves on couch,
oxygen tank on a dolly, ambu bag and catheter on the floor
EF saw the latex gloves on the floor, yet they are pictured on the couch.
Defense R: Close Up photograph of the gloves on the couch
Chernoff shows a picture of the saline bag, with water droplets.
(I don't know if this is an exhibit or just a picture he pulled up
on his ipad)
Chernoff reviews people's 19: blueprints of the second floor
Ed Winters mentioned the bathroom on the 25th.
Ed Winters investigated the bathroom on the 26th.
Defense S: Urine bottle on the chair (also people's 125)
Defense T: wider shot of the the chair w/the bottle of urine on it
Defense U: even wider bedroom shot, urine bottle on chair
Defense V: EF standing in a doorway, hallway
Defense W: Outside (front?) of the residence, EF, police, cars
Defense X: close-up shot of prescription bottles, bayer aspirin,
and fiji water
Defense Y: black bag containing starline blood pressure cuff, bottles (June 29th)
Chernoff reviews people's 162: the saline bag on the IV stand,
syringe attached, depressed plunger
Defense Z: IV line from a different angle, the tubing moved positions when compared
to people's exhibit 162; you can also see the starline box on the dresser.
Digital copy of People's 162 from Chernoff's ipad:
Defense AA: another angle of the same area; picture of Paris has been straightened out,
DVD cover no longer covered by a book; can clearly see the tubing dangling/
wrapped around a knob on the IV stand. Not moved by EF.
None of this (IV stand with the saline bag with the syrine and tubing)
was described in EF's notes, initial report, nor investigative narrative.
EF collected medical records from:
- Dr. Murray
- Dr. Arnold Klein
- Dr. Allan Metzger
- Dr. David Adams
- Dr. Mark Tadrissi
- Dr. David Slavit
- Dr. Randy Rosen
- Nurse Cherilyn Lee
- UCLA Medical Center
- Dr. Koplin (???)
- Dr. Hoefflin (???)
Side Note (not mentioned):
Aliases:
- Michael Joseph Jackson
- Omar Arnold
- Paul Farance
- Paul Farnce
- Bryan Singleton
- Mike Jackson
- Mick Jackson
- Mic Jackson
- Jack London
- Michael Amir Williams Muhammad
- Jimmy Nicholas
- Blanca Nicholas
- Roselyn Muhammad
- Prince Jackson
- Faheem Muhammad
- Frank Tyson
- Fernand Diaz
- Peter Madonie
- Josephine Baker
- Kai Chase
as listed in the search warrant {http://abcnews.go.com/images/US/ht_Scan001_090730.PDF}
EF took the "people's 104" photograph, did not collect juice bottle.
*Judge Pastor's idea to go "BB" instead of "AB".
Defense BB: Naked Juice Bottle
EF the only one collecting evidence on the 25th.
EF doesn't recall taking the picture in defense BB.
June 27th - before returning to scene on the 29th, EF wrote down a description of the IV stand,
IV tubing, saline bag, and the syringe in case notes; EF had them photographed on the 25th
then upon returning to the scene on june 29th, EF took custody of those items and brought them
into coroner's evidence as medical evidence #2
March 29th 2011, EF reviewed items in company of Walgren and Dr. Rogers at which time Dr. Rogers
indicated the item on the floor was an IV Catheter; it was then that EF found out the catheter
did not fit onto the syringe.
Defense CC: (same as people's 135)
in this case, EF felt it necessary to take a picture of the plastic bag inside the blue costco bag to document it,
but did not feel it necessary to document the bottle of propofol inside the saline bag. (as shown in people's 28)
Defense DD: picture of the outside of the house?
Defense EE: prescription pill bottles on a ledge
Defense FF: picture of the bathroom
People's 167: three page stipulation regarding fingerprints
"Fingerprint analysis was conducted in this case by the LAPD
crime lab. The following is a summary of the fingerprint analysis
results:
People's 30 (LAPD item #106) the 100mL propofol vial had one left
index fingerprint; this left index fingerprint was matched to
defendant Conrad Murray.
People's 118 (LAPD item #142) the syringe had one thumbprint;
this thumbprint was matched to coroner investigator Elissa Fleak.
The following item was printed, four identifiable fingerprints were
obtained from the item, no identification was made. That item being:
people's 29 (LAPD item #110) the saline bag with cut.
The following items were printed, two identifiable fingerprints were
obtained from these items, no identification was made. Those items
being: people's 156 (LAPD item #112) saline bag and people's 102
(LAPD item #104) a 20 mL propofol vial.
The following item was printed, one identifiable fingerprint was
obtained from the item, no identification was made. That item being:
people's 136 (LAPD item #107) a 20mL propofol vial.
In regards to items people's 29, people's 156, people's 102, and
people's 136 just mentioned the following individuals were manually
compared to the identifiable fingerprints and were eliminated as
the source of the fingerprint(s). Those people being:
- Conrad Murray
- Michael Jackson
- Alberto Alvarez
- Michael Amir Williams
- Faheem Muhammad
- Mark Goodwin
- Scott Smith
- Martin Blount
- Jimmy Nicholas
- Blanca Nicholas
- Elissa Fleak
- Kai Chase
The following items were printed and no fingerprints were obtained.
This means, although the items may have been touched or handled, no
fingerprints were obtained that could be used for either identification
or elimination. These items being:
- people's 138 (LAPD item #108) 2 midazolam vials
- people's 137 (LAPD item #109) 1 lorazepam vial
- people's 132 (LAPD item #113) 2 lidocaine vials
- people's 132 (LAPD item #114) 1 lidocaine vial
- people's 150 (LAPD item #116) eyedrops
- people's 149 (LAPD item #117) tube marked BQ/KA/RA
- people's 148 (LAPD item #118) bottle of marked ephedrin/caffeine/asprin
- people's 142 (LAPD item #119) 2 100mL propofol vials
- people's 143 (LAPD item #120) 7 20 mL propofol vials
- people's 144 (LAPD item #121) 2 lidocaine vials
- people's 144 (LAPD item #122) 1 lidocaine vial
- people's 147 (LAPD item #123) 2 lorazepam vials
- people's 146 (LAPD item #124) 4 flumazenil vials
- people's 145 (LAPD item #125) 3 midazolam vials
- people's 157 (LAPD item #112) IV Tubing
- people's 158 (LAPD item #112) IV y-connector tubing
- people's 159 (LAPD item #112) Syringe w/needle "
another stipulation: Next witness Dan Anderson (supervising criminalist in forensic
laboratories of LA county coroner's office) is qualified and capable
of testifying to all the toxicology results in this case and that
should he testify to the results obtained by other analysts and
criminalists, defense counsel would be waiving any hearsay objection
to such testimony.
Anderson used the blood vials provided by EF to run toxicology examinations
(patient ID# 3975944) "Trauma Gershwin" as well as autopsy specimens.
EF hand-delivered the speciments to Anderson.
People's 168: Forensic Science Laboratories: Laboratory Analysis Summary Report
8-page report; Dated July 15th 2009
http://cnninsession.files.wordpress.com/2011/10/toxicologyreport.pdf
(some screen caps of the first page)
People's 169: Summary of Positive Findings
The only thing found in his blood/urine was Propofol, Lidocaine, Diazepam,
Nordiazepam, Lorazepam, Midazolam (Versed?), Ephedrine
No demerol in his system.
Peoples 170: Diagram
A: Saline Bag (p. 156)
B: Syringe (p. 159)
C: Y Connector ( p. 158)
D: Short Tube (p. 158)
E: Clear Tip (p. 160) Cut the tip for possible DNA matches
F: Long Tube (p. 157)
G: White Clamp (p. 157)
H: White Thumb Clamp (p. 157)
I: IV Bag Plug (p. 157)
goes into IV Bag
People's 171: 7/15/09 (July 15th 2009)
Medical Evidence #1
Medical Evidence #2
what was found on the IV aparatus
no drugs in saline bag
Defense GG: "Pactox" Laboratory Report
Lorazepam 634 ng/mL = 0.634ug/ml
Defense HH: photograph of the IV stand
Dan Anderson did a toxicology report of the IV
(Medical Evidence #2)
No lidocaine in IV
propofol, lidocaine, flumazenil were found in the syringe
